‘It Lives Inside Review: A Generic Horror Movie Tries To Mine Scares From The Complexity Of Being A FirstGeneration Immigrant
Horror films are particularly good at giving tangible form to our more abstract demons (our fears, our traumas, our forbidden desires, etc.), so it often seems a bit perverse when a genre exercise decides to tap into its potential through creation. of a mined monster. that we cannot really see. As dull and disappointing as the actual results may be, Bishal Dutta's It Lives Inside at least has good reason to choose a creature portrayed (mostly) through sounds and shadows; The negative energy of his victims, and the visibility itself, is the greatest source of this negative energy among the Indian-American high school girls with whom the creatures party at the beginning of the film.
With Never Had star Megan Surry (who is far more skilled than this film demands), Samida is in the bathroom of her immigrant parents' home, shaving black hair off her arms. Then there's a preschool Instagram selfie in which her face is lit up with a "Los Angeles" filter, which has never been more loaded. When her traditional-minded mother (Neeru Bajwa as Poona) speaks to her in Hindi during breakfast, Samida replies, I'm sorry, Sam , in unaccented English. No, he will not help me prepare the prasad. No, she will not wear a dupatta to school. Sam wants to fit in with the other kids in his seemingly ordinary suburb of Vancouver (we never get a clear idea of the city or its dynamics) and sees his cultural heritage as the biggest obstacle to doing so . How ironic that Sam's tortured Indianness so completely defines the main character of a film that doesn't bother to give him other qualities.
More from IndieWire
With that in mind, it's all the more interesting that Dutta's script pays little attention to how Sam has been marginalized since his family came to America for his father's work; There's a detour to John Winthrop's grim town on a hill, but that's about it. That's partly because Dutta's script doesn't do much more than give cultural appropriation the most basic "Babadook" treatment, and partly because Sam's efforts seem to be paying off.
She does well in school, the prettiest boy in her class (a slightly Bieber-esque Gage Marsh) has a crush on her, and she's no longer attached to the other Indian girl in her class (Mohana Krishnan as Tamira). , who plays Tamira. super weird lately. Sam gave up on their friendship when Tamira refused to act whiter, and there doesn't seem to be much hope for reconciliation when her ex-best friend walks around completely confused with a pile of raw meat and a glass jar. . He claims to be possessed by an evil spirit. A glass container that, according to her, she cannot hold alone. A glass container... which Sam immediately throws and breaks on the dressing room floor. The problem is solved!
Ugh, but now there's a vampire on the loose on campus, and he wastes no time grabbing Tamira by the hair and locking her in an abandoned basement, where she'll have to rot in her own horror for seven days ahead. for the demon to devour her flesh. This gives Sam a week to find his friend, which is made even more difficult by the fact that Pishacha is very hostile to anyone who can help his potential victims, or as it may be, the person he likes. Sam, his mother or even his girlfriend. the teacher. (Get Out, Betty Gabriel star): Anyone who can help someone who is helping their potential victims.
How reasonable is it to incorporate a social component into the fabric of a horror film ostensibly about Sam's place in his adopted homeland, distributing the personal burden of his perceived differences among other members of the community and the actual process of Sam's observation. a vampire. film. The quest for these characters is extremely boring and generic. A series of terrifying dream sequences do little to heighten the tension or advance the plot, and Dutta, a first-time director, hasn't developed the skills to translate horrors into his film as specifically as Semin. about your immigration experience.
The entire middle section of this film is dressed in a kind of muddy red color palette that's meant to create atmosphere, but only serves to drown out any sense of place or individuality. It's wasted on paper-thin characters who are attacked by a transparent force. The only thing less satisfying than watching someone on a swing get hit by an invisible demon is watching someone else get chased down the stairs by an invisible demon (Duta is artificially amused by using a mirror and a stopwatch, but the long sequence of "the monster approaching Betty Gabriel at school underscores the director's inability to plant new scares in extremely familiar settings. Of course, it's hard not to appreciate Dutta's forethought when we finally see clearly the monster; SyFy Channel's CGI proves something of a saving grace, as even the film's climax focuses its attention on Suri's face as Sam confronts the possible horrors before the denial of the past.
And yet, the evolution of Sam's relationship with his heritage is so neglected that Suri's close relationships can only be interpreted through the Kuleshov effect. At the end, there's a late, supposedly enlightening conversation between him and his mother (made redundant by slightly misconstrued dialogue like "It's like everything I want outside of me is inside me and I can't get it out")). . But this speech seems only to confirm the reactionary conservatism rarely found in such a modern vision of the immigrant experience. While Dutta inevitably finds a way (and a clever way) for Sam to reconcile the two sides of his hybrid identity, It Lives Inside never abandons its punishing streak.
If Pishacha is meant to represent Sam's selfish quest for assimilation, the past he tries to leave behind haunts him through malice and betrayal; If the girl is reluctant to erase this part of herself, she will only succeed in convincing him to keep her away from sin. It's a perfectly valid and sadly shared dynamic between people and their heritage, and it helps explain why Live Within is the rare horror film that benefits greatly from its recent counterpart (a classic whose conflict is resolved). so fast, it acts), but it also completely defies the tropes of a simple genre exercise that in no way fits the complexity of its defining crisis.
NEON will release It Lives Inside in theaters on Friday, September 22.
The best of IndieWire
Subscribe to the Indiewire newsletter. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for the latest news.
Click here to read the full article.
